Share

cover art for Reporters Without Orders Ep 270: Women in media, hazards of local journalism

Reporters Without Orders

Reporters Without Orders Ep 270: Women in media, hazards of local journalism

This week, host Basant Kumar is joined by The Quint’s reporter Himanshi Dahiya, founder of Main Media Tanzil Asif and senior journalist from ETV Bihar Umesh Pandey.  

In view of the World Press Freedom Day, the panel discusses the state of media in India, and the challenges staring it. The conversation is stirred by an acknowledgement of the recent decline in India’s press freedom ranking and the government's subsequent denial on the subject. 

Himanshi takes us through her experiences as a mediaperson and emphasises that media spaces only have a faint presence of women, while men still dominate the landscape. “The male gaze and dominance are still pervasive in the media.” 

Tanzil shares his experience of doing hyper-local journalism, and its hazards in contrast with the mainstream media. He recounts the fears that accompany matters involving local representatives, who often pressure journalists. While Tanzil talks about the onslaught on press freedom, Umesh explains his circumstances as a local journalist in Bihar and how his ground reports led to the filing of FIRs against him. 

This and a lot more, Tune in! 


Timecodes

00:00:00 - Introduction

00:02:36 - Press Freedom 

01:02:42 - Recommendations


Recommendations


Himanshi

NCERT textbook revision: Why it happens every few years & what makes it controversial

Umesh

14 साल बाद भी 38 हजार घरों में नहीं पहुंचा शुद्ध गंगाजल, 2009 में ट्रीटमेंट प्लांट का हुआ था शिलान्यास

Tanzil

बांग्ला भाषा का मतलब ‘घुसपैठ’ कैसे हो गया दैनिक जागरण?

Basant

Delhi riots: Inside the ‘Kattar Hindu’ WhatsApp group that planned, executed murders

Umar Khalid Arrested: What Delhi Riot Charge Sheets Say About Him

No Nation for Women: Journalist Priyanka Dubey on her searing reportage on rape in India

How Varun Gandhi Silenced The System

Produced by Tehreem Roshan, recorded by Anil Kumar, and edited by Umrav Singh. 



More episodes

View all episodes

  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 354: How NL cracked the voter deletion series

    53:02|
    A reporters’ podcast about what made news and what shouldn’t have.NL TeamThis week, host Shivnarayan Rajpurohit is joined by Sumedha Mittal.Sumedha’s series for Newslaundry, Broken Ballots, tracked curious deletions and additions of voters to the electoral rolls. Based on data and fieldwork, she found an odd pattern, which she says places a question mark on the Election Commission. She also cautions that this could be “used as exploitation”, regardless of whoever is in power. Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:02:18 - The Broken Ballots series00:50:20 - RecommendationsRecommendationsSumedhaA day with AAP volunteers who reflect the party’s convoluted social-justice politicsShivnarayanVajpayee: The Ascent of the Hindu Right, 1924–1977Produced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 353: How NYT broke the story of Okhla plant ‘poisoning’ locals

    20:58|
    In November last year, there were a flurry of reports in the Indian media on a waste-to-energy plant in Delhi’s Okhla that causes significant health risks to people living nearby. All these reports cited the same source – an investigative piece in The New York Times by journalist Maria Abi-Habib. Currently based in Mexico, Maria spent five years, between 2019 and 2024, to report on the story. She found the plant, operated by a subsidiary of the Jindal Group, pumps “as much as 10 times the legal amount of dioxins” into Delhi’s skies, and that its workers say it was “never regulated”. In this special episode of Reporters Without Orders, Newslaundry’s Pratyush Deep talks to Maria about how she stumbled upon this story. Her husband had been working on a series on air pollution in India – what Maria describes as “the biggest topic of concern, or should be, for most families and the government”. During the course of it, he met residents of Sukhdev Vihar, where the plant is located.“They said they have been living there for a while and once the plant started, that is when their health problems started,” Maria says. “So, we decided to take a look and what we found was pretty incredible and also a little bit horrifying.”Maria also explains the challenges she faced in reporting the story, and why she thinks Delhi’s air pollution crisis persists. “It is up to the government to take a look at the story and say why this plant is continuing to get the permission to expand its operations, why this Jindal family subsidiary continues to get more plants,” she says, adding that the group has “seven across the nation”. “If they can’t responsibly manage this plant, then why should they be given others?”Produced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar. 
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 352: The scenes behind the best of 2024

    52:42|
    It’s the New Year special episode with all the Newslaundry reporters in the studio. They talk about the best stories of 2024 and what happened behind the scenes during those assignments.Produced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 351: The decline and fall of Network18?

    51:10|
    This week, host Sumedha Mittal is joined by The Caravan’s Sagar.Sagar talks about his report on Network18 shifting from public interest journalism to what he describes as appeasing the government. He explains how Network18 changed after Ambani took over and how journalists were asked to defend the prime minister. This led to the resignation, even firing, of several journalists, he explained. Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:01:38 - Network18 and Ambani00:49:18 - RecommendationsRecommendationsSagarThe In-depth History of Reservation System| Creamy Layer| Subcategorization Ft. SagarSumedhaUnreliable News How Reliance hollowed out Asia’s largest media conglomerateProduced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 350: UP STF’s ‘fake encounters’, Nita Ambani’s life and PR

    59:35|
    This week, host Tanishka Sodhi is joined by independent journalist Akanksha Kumar and the Caravan’s Amrita Singh.Akanksha reported on the alleged fake encounter of one Bhalchandra Yadav by the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force. She delves into the workings of the UP STF, the state of law and order in UP, and a purportedly normalised trend of police encounters in the state.Amrita’s report was a deep dive on Nita Ambani, wife of billionaire businessman Mukesh Ambani, her life, and her quest for the public eye. She talks about Nita’s involvement in Reliance-Jio World’s major operations and her PR team’s efforts in her positive branding.Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:07:37 - ‘Fake encounter’ by UP STF00:29:06 - Nita Ambani00:55:17 - RecommendationsRecommendationsAmritaJoylandAkankshaSeharTanishka‘Trying a different route’: The new path and ‘positivity’ of Shehla RashidProduced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 349: Illegal vehicles on Delhi roads, aftermath of Sambhal violence

    28:11|
    This week, host Anmol Pritam is joined by Newslaundry’s Avdhesh Kumar.Avdhesh reported on the nexus of middlemen and Delhi police officials allegedly facilitating the plying of illegal vehicles in the capital. He explains the workings of the network and the organised crime happening in broad daylight. He also reported on how Congress leader Rahul Gandhi was stopped from going to Sambhal, where clashes over a mosque’s survey killed five locals. He gave a blow-by-blow account of the aftermath of the Sambhal violence.Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:02:38 - Rahul Gandhi detained on the way to Sambhal00:02:38 - Aftermath of Sambhal violence00:25:45 - Delhi police and the middlemen00:33:20 - RecommendationsRecommendationsAvdheshRajat Sharma & Sudhir Chaudhry Talk Sense on Sambhal! Is TV News Changing? TV Newsance 276AnmolSambhal हिंसा का पूरा सच: परत दर परत | Ground ReportProduced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 348: Inside Sambhal violence, ‘voter suppression’ in UP

    28:16|
    This week, host Pratyush Deep is joined by Newslaundry’s Avdhesh Kumar and Sumedha Mittal.Avdhesh reported on the violence that erupted amid protests against the archaeological survey of Mughal-era Shahi Jama Masjid in Uttar Pradesh’s Sambhal. He delved into how the clashes between police personnel and locals led to the death of six civilians.Sumedha’s report was on the odd dip in voter turnout in the recently concluded by-polls in UP’s Kundarki assembly seat. She found out that of the 435 booths in the constituency, 154 saw a dip in voter turnout amid allegations of voter suppression, especially in the Muslim-dominated areas.Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:01:20 - Sambhal violence00:06:22 - Odd dip in voter turnout00:25:43 - RecommendationsRecommendationsAvdheshMaqboolJaun EliaSumedhaALL WE IMAGINE AS LIGHTPratyushBlinded by the Stars: A Gov't Rating Scheme is Helping Coal Miners Pat Their Own BackProduced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 347: Jhansi fire tragedy, migration in Bundelkhand

    47:34|
    This week, host Basant Kumar is joined by Dainik Bhaskar’s Rajesh Sahu and independent Journalist Sneha Richhariya.Rajesh reported on the Jhansi hospital tragedy, in which a fire incident claimed the lives of 15 infants. He says that an overcrowded NICU, expired fire extinguishers, and negligence of the hospital administration led to the incident.Sneha has reported on the impact of migration in the Bundelkhand region of Uttar Pradesh. She shed light on how families of the migrants are impacted and the pace of migration leading to vacant villages.Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:01:28 - Jhansi hospital fire00:20:43 - Bundelkhand migration 00:33:20 - RecommendationsRecommendationsSnehaLIES OUR MOTHERS TOLD US: The Indian Woman’s BurdenAnurag Minus Verma PodcastBasantEk Jindagi Kafi NahiProduced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.
  • Reporters Without Orders Ep 346: Rahul Gandhi’s YouTube strategy, Maharashtra’s Ladki Bahin scheme

    45:38|
    Host Sumedha Mittal is joined by Newslaundry’s Tanishka Sodhi and Shivnarayan Rajpurohit.Tanishka reported on the Ladki Bahin scheme, launched recently by the Maharashtra government for women in the poll-bound state. She explains whether this scheme, the Mahayuti’s biggest bet this election, holds currency for voters.  to multiple women and tries to make out that the newly minted scheme is Mahayuti’s biggest bet this election.Shivnarayan talks about his deep dive on Rahul Gandhi’s formula to win on YouTube and social media. He says Gandhi’s team uses strategies that are no different from those used by Narendra Modi. He also explains how Gandhi’s team is sidelining mainstream media, since they believe the media played a huge role in establishing Gandhi’s image as “Pappu”. Tune in.Timecodes00:00:00 - Introduction00:00:59 - Ladki Bahin scheme00:11:33 - Rahul Gandhi’s YouTube channel00:44:01 - RecommendationsRecommendationsTanishkaImbalance of power: Women at international climate negotiationsShivnarayanWho was behind the NCP split? Ajit Pawar's BIG REVEAL to Sreenivasan JainProduced and edited by Saif Ali Ekram, recorded by Anil Kumar.